“Why should the readers give a stuff?” Is your story worth telling?

Getting media attention can be tough, even for people who’ve made it a career.

For my first ever phone pitch to a tech journo, I nervously drafted a script to prepare. It covered the product’s features, founder info and how it benefited the customer. I practised it and then dialled:

  • Journalist: “I’m on deadline. You have one minute.”
  • Me: Launches into the script without taking a single breath for the entire minute…
  • Journalist: “And why should the readers give a stuff about this?” Listens to me stuttering for a bit, then hangs up.
  • Me: Insert long-running expletive starting with F here.

And this was before we had AI flooding media inboxes and a shrinking pool of journalists. You now have three seconds or less to cut through.

So what went wrong with my pitch?

It left out the most important thing: the audience. Media attention - whether news, Substack, podcasts or social commentators - isn’t about what you want to say.

It’s asking why what you want to say matters to the audience.

Is the story strong enough?

The media remains an important channel for startups. Getting featured helps founders build credibility with investors, talent and customers. It also increases search visibility, with 84% of AI platforms citing earned media and third-party sources (Muck Rack).

However, deciding whether a story is worth telling takes time and interrogation. Here are some questions to help you:

  • Is it unique? This can come in many forms. Are you doing something that no one else is? What can you offer that no one else has? This could be a contrary point of view backed up with data, or a new product solving a problem on the news agenda. Journalists are crying out for a unique take.

“I wake up and start my workday to hundreds of new pitches every day. I’d guess 85% of the pitches are AI-related... If you plan to pitch something AI-related to the media, your hooks need to be incredibly unique.” - Kimanzi Constable, freelance journalist writing for Business Insider, Forbes and Fast Company

  • Is it measurable? For startups, this is crucial. You can have the most innovative idea in the world, but there’s no story to tell if you can’t prove it works. Start with the outcomes: time saved, revenue generated, processes improved, etc. Case studies help contextualise your impact for the audience.
  • Is it human? Have you overcome challenges to get where you are? Does your story have tension in the form of hurdles, roadblocks or risk? Have you experienced something the average person can relate to? Lean into the founder journey if you have something interesting to share.
  • Is it recognisable? Do you have a big-name investor or partner? Have you founded and exited other successful startups? Do you have a notable or impressive CV?
  • Can it be understood? This is one of the biggest hurdles for early-stage startups. If you can’t explain what your business does simply and in plain English, the audience won’t get it.

If you’re planning to pitch the media yourself, here are some quick-fire tips:

  • Keep it short: Emails should be fewer than 150 words and cover what the story is, why it matters to the audience and what you have to offer (case studies, data, commentary, financials, press releases, etc.). The subject line is your most important lever for getting seen.
  • Give it time: “I’m launching tomorrow” is not enough notice. Journalists need time to review and consider a story. On that note, don’t follow up the next day. Give it at least a week.
  • Do your research: To find the right fit, look for journalists who cover your industry, or have featured startups similar to yours. Read the publications regularly before pitching and use common sense: the Australian Financial Review won’t consider you without impressive financials that can be shared publicly.

Related articles